For plato, a governing body is essential because it takes the very best people society has to offer and puts them in power to act as the moral and political guidance system for the other classes of citizens. Plato s teacher, socrates, was killed by athenian democracy. Political philosophy, by steven cahn 1197 words 5 pages. In this course, we will examine some of the seminal texts in the history of political philosophy. Agarwal,20 in short political philosophy is the activity with all the philosophers such as plato,aristotle,machiavelli,karlmarx,johnhobbes,locke,rousseau whereby the. In response, he developed a political philosophy that emphasized three key concepts. Aristotle was a scientist rather than a prophet, and his politics, written while he was teaching at the. Compare and contrast the theories of plato, aristotle. The political of political science essay 2347 words 10 pages. He argues that man is essentially motivated by a desire for selfpreservation. Kant held that every rational being had both an innate right to freedom and a duty to enter into a civil condition governed by a social contract in order to realize and preserve that freedom. Intellectual historians want to look at the past to find questions of value.
Central to his political theory is a conception of human nature based on these material conditions of human existence. Like many philosophers before him, hobbes wants to present a more solid and certain account of human morality than is contained in everyday beliefs. Because of this he came to the conclusion that people were unfit to rule themselves and a strong state was needed to protect the people. In steven cahn s book, political philosophy, the essential texts, philosophers such as socrates, plato, aristotle, hobbes, locke and rousseau created the circumstances to enable the fundamental principals of philosophy. Yet the only evidence he produces concerns hobbes s doctrine of the natural war of all against all which, according to him. Plato describes the nature of justice in this influential work of political philosophy, the republic. Unlike the elements of law, which was composed in english for english parliamentariansand which was written with local political challenges to charles i in mindde cive. Plato, aristotle, hobbes, rousseau, tocqueville, zizek this, then, my friend, said i, is the fine and vigorous root from which tyranny grows, in my opinion.
The ancient political debate between plato and aristotle is important to modern political philosophy as it is the basis of modern political theories. Thomas hobbes april 5, 1588december 4, 1679 and john locke august 29, 1632october 28, 1704, although in agreement in some of their assertions about human nature and the need for government, held radically different perspectives about the ability of people to govern themselves. The political philosophies of thomas hobbes and john locke. Aristotle, who was a pupil in the academy of plato, remarks that all the writings of plato are original. What is the difference between political philosophy and. For hobbes, the english civil war significantly shaped his worldview. Consistent with lockes claims that the purpose of society is protect the security of each members. Thomas hobbes had more of a platonic view to political philosophy. In philosophy, he defended a range of materialist, nominalist, and empiricist views against cartesian and aristotelian alternatives. For plato, the state seems largely an imitative and illusory kingly art, having almost the lowest. Plato wrote that he would never write down what he most intimately believed on any subject seventh letter.
Hobbes and the political thought of plato and aristotle. Directly or indirectly, he has set the terms of debate about the fundamentals of political life right into our own times. Hobbes, the right to rule reduces simply to the sovereigns ability to stay in power and this power must come from the governed. My first enquiry was to be from whence it proceeded, that any man should call any thing rather his owne, than another mans hobbes 1983 1647, pp. Instead, hobbes sought to ground his political theory in the natural world, the world of real human beings with real limitations and vulnerabilities. This is much more important to political philosophy than one might think. Hobbes is the founding father of modern political philosophy.
A summary of plato s political theory and american politics 2016 october 24, 2016 plato, politics general john messerly plato argued that we cant have a good life without good government, and he also believed that we cant have good governments without intellectually and morally excellent leaders. Political philosophers such as, aristotle and plato have more of an ancient conception of liberty and the role the individual plays in society and to the state. Thomas hobbes 15881679, whose current reputation rests largely on his political philosophy, was a thinker with wideranging interests. Political philosophy is a part of the western intellectual tradition, and this tradition is composed of two elements. In his opinion, human nature is the the combined result of mechanic desires and aversions, arbitrated by constant power struggles. Pdf comparison of platos political philosophy with. To view the pdf, you must log in or become a member. There is a diverse amount of themes that could be compared in.
Among his sparring partners the dearest to him was not a contemporary such as descartes, white, bramhall, or wallis but aristotle. Thomas hobbe s political philosophy thomas hobbes was born in england and lived during a time of religious strife and absolutism. Hobbes is famous for his early and elaborate development of what has come to be known as social contract theory, the method of justifying political principles or arrangements by appeal to the agreement that would be made among. The same malady, i said, that, arising in oligarchy, destroyed it, this. But perfection in everything is perhaps a difficult thing. He posited that there is no true right and wrong but that morality is subjectively relative. Political philosophy or political theory is concerned with normative. Comparing the social contracts of hobbes and locke murdoch. This is an assumption that he shares with the majority of modern political philosophers.
Whereas, thomas hobbes, john locke, and john stuart mill have developed a more modernized conception of liberty and the role of the individual to the state and society. Locke and hobbes both share a vision of the social contract as instrumental in a states. Hobbes philosophy of science stanford encyclopedia of. We will begin with classical and medieval thinkers such as plato, aristotle, augustine and aquinas, and then we will trace the writings of. Hobbes, aristotle, and human happiness during his life in philosophy thomas hobbes engaged in several debates. Hobbes grounds his political philosophy by exploring human nature. John lockes greatness as a philosopher is based on his theories on childhood, his work on religious toleration and his concept of the rights of citizens. Property and ownership stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. So, political philosophy is the study of topics such as politics,liberty,justice,rights,property,law and the enforcement of a legal code by authority. Both plato and hobbes recognized that without a hierarchy of some kind, society would crumble and citizens would give into their appetites, aversions, and desires. First part says that the aim of the contract is to protect and defend the common goods of each member.
Hobbes and plato both constructed images of an ideal state, based on their. Because hobbes held that the true doctrine of the lawes of nature is the true morall philosophie, differences in interpretation of hobbes s moral philosophy can be traced to differing understandings of the status and operation of hobbes s laws of nature, which laws will be discussed below. Schuhmann, selected papers on renaissance philosophy and on thomas hobbes. Hobbes antiplatonic theory of eros for his own political thought and, more. Martin bertman, hobbes science of politics and plato s laws, the independent journal of philosophy 2 1978, p. Both plato and hobbes arguably assign the state a very low ontological status indeed.
He posited that there is no true right and wrong but that morality is. Thomas hobbes and john locke both have made contributions to modern political science and they both had similar views on where power lies in a society. Plato set the mode of discourse, he raised most of the issues, topics and questions that the later philosophers dealt with. Hobbess moral and political philosophy stanford encyclopedia of. Comparison of the republic by plato and leviathan by. Plato created idealism and aristotle, later recuperated by thomas aquinas, became the. The 17 th century english philosopher thomas hobbes is now widely regarded as one of a handful of truly great political philosophers, whose masterwork leviathan rivals in significance the political writings of plato, aristotle, locke, rousseau, kant, and rawls. He viewed humans, in their natural state, as aggressive and brutish. Therefore all his dialogues are heuristics for readers. The state would regulate everything as a secular entity. Compared philosophies undeniably, plato and aristotle are the two rock stars of greek philosophy.
Not really a question that can be answered satisfactorily on a forum like this. Political philosophy of plato, locke, and aquinas, and. His writings on political philosophy consist of one book and several shorter works. To put it crudely and briefly, political science investigates empirical questions about the way politics work, for example, what is the explanation for the cuban missile crisis.
First, hobbes himself understood his political philosophy, or as he called it civil philosophy, to be a science capable of demonstration. Pdf thomas hobbes and the political economy of peace. Thomas hobbes and plato s the leviathan and the republic. Greeks are considered the start of political philosophy. Platonic view of eros and his teaching on the primacy of power in. He is best known for his thoughts on social and political order, and reasoned why we should give our full obedience to the government in order to avoid the state of. A summary of the political philosophy of john locke and thomas hobbes, especially as it relates to the american revolution.
Hobbes presented his political philosophy in different forms for different audiences. One part derives from the philosophical tradition of greece, but. Political philosophy political philosophy aristotle. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. For hobbes, property rules were the product of authoritythe acknowledged authority of a sovereign, whose. What are the differences and similarities of plato. Thus, understanding his general views about the nature of scientific demonstration promises to shed light on the way in which he saw civil philosophy as scientific. Hobbes builds on a conception of political philosophy as developed by the ancients.
Political philosophy, thomas hobbes plato and leviathan by plato vs. Hobbes is famous for his early and elaborate development of what has. Indeed hobbes regarded property as the key to political philosophy. Hobbess moral philosophy has been less influential than his political. For hobbes, the social contract is arguably like a doughnut hole. References to platos works, too, are given in the text.
1099 440 1248 577 1408 412 1112 1325 356 1589 563 318 1192 109 137 563 1307 945 1107 692 595 290 1455 121 284 1341 1463 1038 964 596 90 1404 15 730 528 1331 209 703